Life insurance claim delayed? A 30-day plan for families

When a claim drags, families tell us the hardest part is not knowing what is happening or whether they are allowed to push. You are. A beneficiary is not asking for a favor, and most insurers are working against legal deadlines whether they mention them or not.

This plan covers the first 30 days after you realize a claim is not moving. It will not fit every case, but it gives the month a shape.

Days 1 to 3: start a claim log

Open one notebook or one document and keep everything about the claim there. At the top, write:

• The insurer’s name, the policy or certificate number and the claim number.
• The name and direct phone number or email of the person handling the claim.
• The date you sent the claim form, and how you sent it.
• The date you sent the certified death certificate, if it went separately.

Then, for every contact, add a line: date, who you spoke with, what they said, what they asked for, and what they promised to do next. Short notes are fine. What matters is that they are written the same day.

The single most important date in the log is when the insurer received the proof of death and the completed claim form. Many of the deadlines below run from that point, and it is often a date the insurer knows and the family does not. Ask for it.

Week 1: find out which clock applies

There is no single national deadline for paying a life insurance claim. Which rules apply depends mostly on two things: whether the coverage came through a private employer, and which state’s law governs the policy. Let’s look at several examples:

A policy governed by Louisiana law

Louisiana gives insurers 60 days from receipt of due proof of death to settle a death claim on a policy issued or delivered in the state. An insurer that misses that window without just cause owes 8% annual interest on the amount due, running from the day it received the proof until it pays (La. R.S. 22:1811).

A policy governed by Texas law

Texas sets a sequence of steps in Chapter 542 of its Insurance Code, which covers claims by beneficiaries and applies to life insurers (Tex. Ins. Code §§ 542.051, 542.052):

• Within 15 days after notice of the claim, the insurer must acknowledge it, begin its investigation, and request the items it reasonably believes it will need from the claimant (§ 542.055(a)).
• Within 15 business days after it receives everything it asked for, the insurer must tell the claimant in writing whether it accepts or rejects the claim (§ 542.056(a)). If it needs more time, it must say why, and then decide no later than 45 days after that notice (§ 542.056(d)).
• Within 5 business days after notifying the claimant that it will pay, the insurer must pay (§ 542.057(a)).
• If it delays payment beyond the deadline set by another applicable statute, or, where no other statute sets one, for more than 60 days after receiving the items it reasonably requested, it owes damages under § 542.060 (§ 542.058(a)).

An insurer that is liable for a claim and does not comply with these rules must pay the beneficiary, in addition to the claim, interest at 18% a year as damages, together with reasonable and necessary attorney’s fees (§ 542.060(a)).

Coverage through a private employer (ERISA)

When a private company provides group life insurance to its workers, federal law usually treats that coverage as an ERISA benefit plan. The claims regulation gives the plan 90 days after the claim is received to decide it. It can stretch that once, by as much as another 90 days, but only by notifying you in writing within the original 90 days and telling you both the special circumstances and when it expects to rule (29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(f)(1)). Time is counted from the filing of the claim under the plan’s procedures, even if some information was still missing at that point (§ 2560.503-1(f)(4)).

If a plan does not follow these procedures, the regulation treats the claimant as having exhausted the plan’s remedies, which can open the door to filing suit (§ 2560.503-1(l)(1)).

Everywhere else

Other states have their own statutes, and some policies say which state’s law governs. If you are not sure, write that question at the top of your log. It is one of the first things we sort out when a family calls.

Week 2: answer requests carefully, and only once

Insurers almost always ask for something. A certified death certificate, a claimant’s statement, proof of identity and sometimes a beneficiary form are routine. Send them promptly by a method you can track, keep a copy of every page, and write the date in your log.

Some requests deserve a pause before you answer:

• Broad medical or records authorizations for the person who died, especially within the first two years of the policy.
• Requests for a recorded interview with you or other family members.
• Questionnaires about the deceased’s health, habits or travel that go well beyond the cause of death.

These often mean the insurer is reviewing the original application. You can ask in writing why the request is needed. Our page on contestability and rescission explains why that review matters.

When you send documents, include a short cover note listing exactly what is enclosed. That way, if the insurer later says something is missing, your log and your cover note show what it already has.

Week 3: ask for a written status

Phone calls are easy for an insurer to forget. A short letter or email is not. Something like this is enough:

I am the beneficiary on claim number ___. You received the claim form and certified death certificate on ___. Please confirm in writing whether you need anything else to decide the claim, and if so, what and why. If you need nothing further, please tell me when you expect to decide.

Louisiana’s unfair claims practices statute lists conduct such as failing to acknowledge and act reasonably promptly on communications about claims, and not confirming or denying coverage within a reasonable time once proof of loss statements are complete (La. R.S. 22:1964(14)(b), (e)). Because the statute is aimed at insurers that do these things as a pattern, it works mainly as a yardstick for regulators. Still, it tells you what prompt handling is supposed to look like, and a written request makes the timeline clear.

If the coverage is through an employer, this is also the week to request the plan documents in writing from the plan administrator, which is often the employer rather than the insurer. Federal law requires the administrator, on written request from a participant or beneficiary, to furnish the latest summary plan description and the instruments under which the plan operates, and it may charge a reasonable copying fee (29 U.S.C. § 1024(b)(4)). An administrator that does not mail requested material within 30 days may, in the court’s discretion, be personally liable for up to $100 a day (29 U.S.C. § 1132(c)(1)), an amount the Department of Labor has adjusted to $110 a day (29 C.F.R. § 2575.502c-1).

Week 4: decide whether you need help

By the end of the month, read your log from the top. Some patterns are signs that a claim is not just slow:

• You keep hearing that the file is “with legal” or “in contestable review,” and nobody will give a date.
• Requests keep changing, or the same document is requested twice.
• A second person has claimed the money, or the insurer questions the beneficiary designation.
• The cause or manner of death is listed as “pending” and the insurer is waiting on it.
• An employer and an insurer each say the other one has the paperwork.

None of these means the claim will be denied. They do mean the claim has moved from processing into a dispute, or close to one. Our page on delayed life insurance claims describes how we work to get a stalled claim decided, and a lawyer can tell you which of the deadlines above applies and whether interest or fees may be owed.

Sources

1. La. R.S. 22:1811. Louisiana State Legislature.
2. La. R.S. 22:1964(14)(b), (e). Louisiana State Legislature.
3. Tex. Ins. Code §§ 542.051, 542.052, 542.055(a), 542.056(a) and (d), 542.057(a), 542.058(a), 542.060(a). Texas Constitution and Statutes.
4. 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(f)(1), (f)(4), (l)(1). Electronic Code of Federal Regulations.
5. 29 U.S.C. § 1024(b)(4). Legal Information Institute.
6. 29 U.S.C. § 1132(c)(1). Legal Information Institute.
7. 29 C.F.R. § 2575.502c-1. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations.

Written by Stephanie Prestridge, an attorney at Life Claim. Treat this post as general information rather than legal advice; reading it does not make you a client of the firm. Policies, plans and state laws vary and are amended over time, and the outcome of any claim depends on its particular facts. Sources were checked on the date shown above.

More from the Life Claim blog